Cognitive Biblical
Therapy Coursework

Counseling Through God’s
Transformative Word

Course 4, Chapter 4

Materials

Section 2: Issues in Relationships

Chapter 4: First Marriage Dysfunction

A troubled marriage between two active personalities who are strong-willed, quick to explode with extreme emotions like fire and gasoline. Dr. Wilkinson walks the couple through the initial CBT phases into their financial conflicts, involving a Biblical Separation and leading to marital reconciliation and submission to God. Dr. Wilkinson concludes in discussing sexual issues involved in marriages. ‍

Essay Questions: Answering the section questions (red buttons) is a great way to prepare for the end of the Chapter Quiz. Chapter 4 questions require you to analyze the case study and apply both present and previous course understanding, while using common sense. The section questions will provide Dr. Wilkinson’s feedback to your answers.

Quiz Requirement: At the end of the Chapter, a score of 75% is necessary on the Chapter Quiz in order to access the next chapter.

Account Access: You must be logged into the coursework page to take the quiz and advance.

Chapter 4

Dysfunction in a First Marriage

Personality Type Dysfunction’s Impact on a Marriage

The next topic is symptoms of dysfunction within a first marriage, and treatment for those symptoms. Find Case Study 8A: first marriage - active woman and first marriage - active man. In this case, both people were very headstrong, right and wrong thinkers. Do it now; talk to me, type people. Their marriage was filled with power struggles and battles that provide great examples to learn from.  

Question 1. Put the composite score graph of the active woman on your right and the active man on your left. You will find the symptoms of dysfunction on in the Materials Tab (red tab on left side of page). We will review the symptoms first, look at the composite score graph, and discuss the high, medium and low points.  Then we'll go to the treatment of the couple.

Before we discuss their dysfunctional symptoms, I want to encourage you to assess childhood, teenage and young adult years of development, prior to their marriage. While gathering and discussing data from their IDI, carefully probe into identified areas of harm done to them by others, such as: verbal, physical, sexual abuse that may have involved neglect; authoritative and/or legalistic parenting style or lack of parenting; sexual activity, pornography, sexually transmitted diseases; lack of knowing or being taught about God and His Word; controlling behaviors within relationships or dependent relationships. Understanding how past issues brought into their marriage can and will influence their conditional, hurtful behaviors, whether unknowingly or willfully.

Question 2. Looking at the symptoms of First Marriage Dysfunction, you will find extreme emotion, such as yelling, crying, hopelessness, violence, extreme anger and bitterness. Other extreme emotions can be driving like a lunatic and physical abuse, such as hitting, slapping, shoving or blocking a person from leaving the room, or holding against the wall or pinning to the bed.  Anger directed towards the kids can transfer to the other spouse when one tries to intervene. There can be physical or sexual abuse even rape when a husband forces sex with his wife against her will. Another dysfunction is the misuse of alcohol or drugs. Conflict over discipline of children is another dysfunction that results in an unruly family life, children who are either belligerent or withdrawn, depressed and frightened, with poor academic performance. Poor work performance or trouble keeping a job. Another dysfunction is dealing with overly concerned family members and friends or those who seek to take advantage of the couple. There may be sexual dysfunction. Also, they may not be Christians at all. They may have started their whole relationship on nothing that has to do with God: no sense of service, no sense of submission, no knowledge of Biblical principles is going to be a presenting problem. You have to evangelize and lead them to Jesus and accept Him as Savior, and educate them about churches to attend for Christian fellowship. Another dysfunction is adultery. One time, a man I worked with had encouraged his wife to have affairs, and he wanted to do the same thing. She reluctantly went along with it. It was due to pornography. What came out eventually was that there were three more affairs he'd never told her about. When he told her, it was very difficult, but critical to the restoration of this couple. 

Looking at the composite graph for Case Study 8A, we'll start with the woman. She was very bitter, which shows up in her scores. She didn't have much trouble with being boastful (18) or proud (17), or with being self-seeking (17), keeping records of wrong (18), protects (17). She did have trouble with how she processed her information, patience (16). She tended to appear to be envious (16), rude (16) by being pushy, and use manipulative through tone of voice, body language, accusation, and being argumentative. She always looked for the worst case shown by a score of 13 on keeps a record of wrong. Those tendencies are linked with being unkind (12). All of these generated fear, anger, insecurity, and conflict, and being easily angered (11). She could punch his buttons in a blink. She didn't know God at all, so she didn't trust him (8). She didn't have any hope (13) that God would help her even if she'd do it his way. She relied on her own strength and perseverance (9). She was very strong-willed, used a loud voice, with a caustic, sarcastic, sharp tongue. Because of all of those behaviors, she felt like a failure (10) almost all the time. She had a strong-willed father who was very loud, cutting, and very disrespectful. She wanted to do what's right, but was scrunched and harassed during childhood.

Looking at the husband’s scores, you'll notice his extreme scores; he is almost as active- sincere as he could be. Look at his greatest struggles here: kind (7), pride (8), easily angered (8), and delight in evil (9). So, they're both pushy, active, and not very sincere. He had a much lower score on pride than she did. He was a mixture: saying you want to do what's right, yet appears very arrogant, rude and prideful, because he had an affair for almost two years. He also seems to be easily angered (13), so he gets himself and everybody else upset all the time. He also is very negative, so he always looks at the worst, assumes the worst, speaks the worst-case scenario. Whatever is in his brain spills out of his mouth almost immediately. He doesn't trust (5) God either. A big difference in his score on hope (19), probably because of the role model of his grandfather, an Assemblies of God preacher who lived a godly life. He believes God will help him. He'd tell me, “I know there's a God, I've seen it in grandpa.” His grandpa would talk to him and pray with him. His score on perseverance is also high (18). He's had trouble too, with feeling like a failure (13), and also with protects (10) no control over his mouth. He brought up the past a lot, so he'd keep records of wrong (12). Also, he was self-seeking (13). He would tell his kids he'd be there, but pick up his girlfriend and bring her to his house with his kids. He promised his wife that he would change, but did not. He would sneak around, be manipulative, complain, and whine. He was boastful (13) and had an abrasive personality, making it difficult to have a conversation with. He would mock you openly to your face, call you stupid and then laugh. He was also impatient (11), with no way to process issues through the biblical principles or a relationship to God. Looking at their similarities: both of them are unkind, easily angered, neither trust God and both feel like failures. He has a higher sense of who God really is, but these other things cause him to be arrogant. She has less of a problem with pride, but still was unkind and easily angered. Their basic difficulties were never solving problems and getting into power struggles. His adultery added to the complexity. 

Question 3. Thankfully the treatment plan resulted in reconciliation after two years of separation and guidance through counseling. She got her problems resolved, and eventually, he woke up and left his girlfriend. The most effective part was a legal separation which safeguarded the family, so that the wife could heal and change. This stopped the potential divorce hearing. Sometimes, when a spouse is not willing to work on their marriage or marriage counseling is not working, a serious intervention like a Biblical Separation may be warranted. After the willing spouse is abiding in God’s Spirit of reconciling their relationship, he/she can use some natural consequences (limits in conversation, intimacy boundaries and/or time together) to draw attention to the seriousness of their marital issues. Yet when all of the willing spouse’s attempts through prayer does not bring a helpful response by the resistive spouse, the willing spouse may find the use of the process of patience (refer to Course 3, Chapters 1, 2, 3, 7 & Course 4 Chapter 3) in letter form is the necessary step towards the marital reconciliation, cautioning the need for a separation (see example). If the resistive spouse continues their resistance, the willing spouse may find the necessity to write up a separation letter, with the goal of reconciliation of their marriage under the authority of God and His Agape love. Further discussion about this process and optional outline and example will be provided in Chapters 7 & 8.

In the Materials tab, the Symptoms and Treatment Plan tab identifies the need to use the evaluation of their concepts of love, and their personality types through the Agape Love Analysis Profile. I used this case study for the description of Active Personality type. When I first met them, they fought like cats and dogs. She was snippy and sarcastic; he complained, whine and throw back a sharp, nasty response. Although both were active personality types, there is more variance with the man. His highest score was on envy (20), hopes (19), and perseveres (18). His lowest score was on trust (5), which shows that he didn't trust God. He knew of God so he's somewhat active-sincere, but definitely gets into power struggles. 

She is more of a classic active personality in her scores. She's a little bit higher on patience (16) than people usually are and not being boastful (18). These scores show that she wants to think and solve problems. She has some skills on how to confront, while he doesn't have much skill, can seem very erratic, and hard to understand. He had a very low score on patience (11). Often the active-sincere person has a low score on patience. They are not extremely prideful, because they're so erratic, they can appear to be purposely manipulative. I learned during counseling, he wasn't prideful, but had to decide to trust God. He had to learn who God is and was able to submit to the God he now knew. In treatment during the second session, you show them their scores, and explain what you have observed in their interactions and explain why they are in crisis. As you go through the high scores, middle scores, low scores, and personal personality type, they begin to understand the major problems.

Question 1

Fully answer the following question from the content you just read and submit your answer to find your score and Dr. Dan's answer to the question.

Both clients within a first marriage have brought a host of potential problems that may be manifesting themselves within the initial session. List some of these difficulties from their childhood, adolescence and adult life that they may be dealing with at the time of the counselor's intervention into their lives.

Pasting is disabled for this answer box. Please type your answer in your own words.


Dr. Dan's Answer:

There may be issues of sexual abuse, abusive parenting in a demanding or legalistic sense, no parental structure or control at all and extreme sexual activity with complications such as pornography addiction or sexually transmitted diseases. There may also be issues of a spiritual nature such as no knowledge of God or the Scripture. There could also be an extreme jealousy which had been caused by previous relationships.

Question 2

Fully answer the following question from the content you just read and submit your answer to find your score and Dr. Dan's answer to the question.

List some of the major issues that the counselor may have to work with the clients on in this relationship. (Some items will also be found under Question 1.)

Pasting is disabled for this answer box. Please type your answer in your own words.


Dr. Dan's Answer:

  • How to parent
  • Understanding sexuality
  • Building a relationship to God
  • Finances and budgeting
  • Basic concepts of love and communication
  • Healing old wounds
  • Physical and sexual abuse inflicted upon each other
Question 3

Fully answer the following question from the content you just read and submit your answer to find your score and Dr. Dan's answer to the question.

Describe the basic process of a Biblical separation and when it may be appropriate.

Pasting is disabled for this answer box. Please type your answer in your own words.


Dr. Dan's Answer:

Try to accomplish change through counseling first in that a separation is the last thing to do and one of the most intense interventions that the counselor can suggest. If the counseling approach fails, write a letter of separation, work out all plans to separate, give the letter and then be out of touch for a day. If the other person won't counsel, then enact the separation with the accompanying rules (visitation of children, finances, transportation, no contact except for business over the phone, time frame initially for two to six months). At the end of the initial time frame either extend it further, be in counseling to reconcile or divorce. The Holy Spirit is to show the client that is obedient to God the hardness of the other's heart, hence the acceptance of God of the hardness and of the need for the other to go on with life, recover and have a new life devoid of the old tendencies and sin that caused a part of the failure of the relationship, repentance.

In other first marriages, you may have an active type and a passive type, so you would explain that type of interaction.  When the passive type gets quiet and withdraws, because of fear or insecurity, the active type gets scared and pushes. Whatever the scenario, use their scores to explain why they're having trouble, and how they try to solve problems. Once you've done that, you address other areas of difficulties you will see on page nine of your text: budget and financial difficulties, sexual issues, interference by relatives, parents, and friends. For this case study dealing with a first marriage, I will discuss many of these which will be repeated in other cases. When you deal with a blended family and second marriage, they will have many of the same issues, perhaps a different slant, but same issues. 

I will explain the types of problems that cases may have because of the situation like a third marriage with sexual issues, or a couple not married, but living together. The same issues, like budget and finances, will have more complications. For your convenience, you will see the material reprinted but applied to different situations. It is the same for other types of relationships, but slant is different. This way you won’t need to go back to find the treatment on a previous page. For example, helping a blended family will have all of the information over sexual issues will be there for you with everything you need on a page. The pattern will be: find the Case Study, examine the composite score graph, and read the symptoms to understand the problem, look at your results, then look at the issues. So, that's a format for what I'm doing with you. In your course materials are several forms that will help you deal with various presenting problems ranging from creating a budget, to setting up a Biblical Separation. 

Budget and Finances

Our first case uses the forms for budget and financial difficulties. Please find the forms that deal with the budget.: 1) A monthly Budget Analysis of Income and Expenditures & 2) The Easy Guide to A Budget You Love, by Larry Burkett. Find those forms in the Required Written Materials zip file and I will explain how to use them to help a client with financial or budgeting difficulties. 

Many times, you'll have clients who live on credit cards, many which have reached the credit limit. One client had about $12,000 charged with 21% interest. They have a sense of hopelessness and despair about paying them off. Some clients are very angry because one spouse is irresponsible in his or her spending. Sometimes, they're just out of work. Sometimes their children are using their money for bail, cars, or non-payment on co-signed loans. Clients may not know anything about budgeting all, because no one ever taught them. They may not have any spiritual concepts of stewardship or budgeting or asking God for help with their money. Most of them don’t know where their spending patterns come from, or why they are constantly scrambling for money.  Thinking that God would help them with how they spend their money or budget, is very foreign to them. 

The treatment description (see Materials tab) starts with analyzing personality type, coping mechanisms, and spiritual concepts through the analysis questionnaire. You can use the budgeting forms to collect information about expenditures, income, and perhaps how to write letters to the creditors. If the clients are willing to honestly face their financial problems, you can help them. Sometimes, your credibility as a counselor will help them with letters to creditors. In order to do that, you will need the creditor to contact person’s information including the person’s name. You can write a letter that says they're sincere, they're in counseling, and you can negotiate for them, possibly some minimal payment that they will accept. Your counseling tasks will be working with their spiritual concepts to establish, strengthen, and clarify their understanding of stewardship. They will need to learn how God directs choices in finances such as learning to restrain from spending. This will ultimately lead them to spiritual understanding and financial stability. 

First, I asked each person to complete the Monthly Budget Analysis form without discussing it with the other and to the best of their ability and return it at the next session. The reason for this is twofold: 1) to see what they each know, and 2) bring reality to their ideas of the amount of money required to live the lifestyle they have chosen. Most times, they realize how little they know, or how much one knows that the other doesn't. In general, husbands and wives have very little understanding of what it takes for the other person to live a quality life: well fed, well dressed, have a sense of peace, and feel that the hard work they do at the job or at home isn’t wasted. This allows each person to have his own or her own personal sense of having life needs met. For example, my wife doesn't know a whole lot about my Harley Davidson, but when I need a spark plug, I need a spark plug. In contrast, I don't know what it takes for my wife to look as beautiful as she does. When she says she needs makeup, she needs makeup. I want her to look nice, but I don't know how much it costs for her to do that. 

Clients will share their budgets and explain their expenses to each other. People argue and fight over money, because they don't have the foggiest idea what the other person needs. As a counselor, I guide them to just give estimates. At the next session, you start at the top and begin to review the completed form by just stating facts without arguing or giving opinions. You start with the wife and review her facts on the form. Then the husband states his facts on income and expenses. You will need to discuss the differences in their estimates. Help them analyze what their problems currently are. Do they need to increase income, cut expenses, set goals. What is currently happening compared to what they would like to happen. There are many options for reaching those goals. Have them put another set of numbers for their goal amounts. Here is where you can speak to them about tithing. Work through each category of spending to help them understand each other’s ideas. For example, ask how much did you put down for insurance? The one who pays the bills will know more of the actual amount. He may not pay the bills, and thinks they spend $100 per month on house insurance, but since she pays the bills, she knows it is $300 per month. You will see information from both sides, and they will see the reality of their finances. She may also explain the inadequacy of his life insurance at $25,000 with three children at home. This is a place they need to think and pray about. 

If you start with the woman to begin about insurance, then ask the man about investments and savings. How much do you save? How much would you like to invest? You will get a figure that may or may not be accurate. What would you like to save? Be prepared for opposition: “We never can. Oh, this is stupid. Oh, we're pipe dreaming. This will never happen.” Push through it anyway. Reassure them that they may not be doing this now, but God can help you establish what you want to do or should do. So, they will get guidelines as we go through this, as to how much they should save. Ask the other person those same questions. What would you like to save, invest? 

Utilities are usually pretty well understood by both. You may see items you may want to ask about. Are you being excessive? Do you want to set your thermostat down? Telephone expense can be a place to make adjustments on the type phone and type of service plans. This is a good item to discuss and propose adjustments. Ask them what they would like modify. Usually, whoever does the shopping, which often is the woman, understands the food and household expenses. Eating out is very expensive especially for families. Many times, men don’t know the cost of the types of food they prefer. They can be excessive in what they eat, or wanting to live beyond their means. You may find some adjustment here. You may set a goal for reduction, or in some cases, to spend more on higher quality food especially if they are not physically well. You will find that family recreation, medical health and clothing are the most neglected areas. 

The next issue is to discuss what they would like to spend. This is a valid reason to be able to set aside money for recreation and vacations. Many times, couples lose their romance, because they no longer go out together, while dressing to look nice for each other. They become overwhelmed with all of the daily obligations it takes to maintain a family; they no longer have time for each other and that sense of being special to someone evaporates. This category of recreation also includes recreation for the kids. The time set aside and the amount of money doesn’t have to be great, but it helps everyone to look forward to something fun and different. Moving money around from different areas can help get this funded. 

Poor health and dental issues are important to address for the whole family. If you don’t take care of your body, you lose energy, attractiveness and sexual functions. Each person should take on the responsibility for personal health. Men and women need yearly checkups, medications and examinations that prevent disease. Money for medications should be included. You may need to reduce your goal or redirect the money into new types of expenditures, so you can have current and future expenditures.  And the whole point of this is that God wants them to take care of themselves, be healthy, and will empower them to work to have their needs met. Clothing is another category where the same sort of thing can happen, but it's got a little bit different effect. It is important to a woman to have her husband dress in a way that shows self-respect and dignity and attractive. The clothes that create the image. Also, women need to have clothing that gives them a good sense of self respect, and appealing to her husband. This is a deeper issue that they need to think and pray about, to find what is reasonable and possible for them. God wants them to look nice for each other, and represent themselves well to others, and have a sense of personal self-respect. Don’t accept either of them to dismiss themselves as not being good enough or worth having what they need. And usually, you'll find they've neglected it because they have mismanaged their money. Their focus has been on other things.  

Auto expenses include payments and maintenance, age of the car and if some of the work is done by the husband. Often the wife is not aware of costs beyond the monthly payment. House payments and or rent is usually known by both of them. Sometimes housing expense is not in line with what they need or can afford. A house larger than is needed costs more in utilities, taxes, insurance and payment interest. For example, one couple I worked with had an expensive house with high costs, and unneeded space. They had two children, and six bedrooms, two stories with a full finished basement, and three fireplaces. They bought it for all of the wrong reasons. When they really looked at what they had done, they realized that they had to sell the house. 

Sometimes things are inappropriate, incidentals, and others can be anything we haven't listed here. People spend a lot of money on all types of small things like: TV subscriptions, video games, designer coffee, parking, gifts for family, fees and fines, etc.  Have them list all of the incidentals. I've put a note that reads, “Please list all items of debt on the reverse side of this sheet, along with the monthly payments for each debt, carry the total payments per month into the column marked others.” Once you have totals for each category, divide the totals into months, and the net income into months. This will show them why they are having financial difficulties. Go back through the expenses with them, to negotiate or compromise on any given expense. You're doing this through prayer. This will be a quantum leap for them. 

Question 4. Remind them of the process of patience: What are the facts? For example, one couple had, I think, $353 over on their first attempt run through at their budget. One item or two items we looked at were cable TV and pool chemicals. They had a large in-ground pool, so we discussed the cost of maintenance for it. We discussed the TV subscriptions and Wi-Fi costs which included many extra options.  What are the facts? What are your feelings about all of this? They were anxious about giving up what they liked. I asked them to pray about what they were outing in their mind. What does God think about how this supports you spiritually? The Bible doesn’t approve of being over your budget and viewing sinful activities. You will need to think and pray about what Jesus would do. You're going to have to ask the Holy Spirit to show you what you need to do. Spending money on something that is bad for you is creating financial instability. 

The other example, is the maintenance of a large swimming pool. This pool was costing them about $200 a month in chemicals. We used the same process of facts, feelings and perspectives. This was a luxury they really didn't need. They gathered facts about usage, chemical treatments and learned they use the pool about two months out of the year. They also learned that the pool doesn’t require the amount they were using. After praying about it, they decided to not use it as early or late in the year, which would save about ¼ of the cost of chemicals. The next expense we examined was the telephone. We discussed the cost of the phones, service plans and what they pay for, but don’t use to find more savings.  What will happened is the money begins to shift from areas of over spending to areas where it is really more needed. Through this process they will have a better sense of what they need now. This first budget is not set in stone, but a beginning. After a month, you check with them and see how they can adjust it further. Use patience again. Check out your motive. See what you're doing. See if you need to keep it there. Keep going through the process of prayer and evaluation and communication with each other so that you understand what the needs are, and work on debt reduction. So, you keep working on focus, priorities, prayer, and submission to the Holy Spirit. 

In this particular case, both were active type personalities. They were power strugglers, and while working on this issue, he would spend money and not talk to her first. He felt entitled. She would seek relief and happiness through buying things she liked. Both of them had to stop manipulating each other with their spending. They needed to learn and practice the process of patience with life issues. As they got better at this type of communication, they gave each other feedback about whether an expense was reasonable or workable. 

That second form is from Crown Financial Ministries (Money Wise), Larry Burkett. His 5 step model works well for clients, describes the steps to set up a budget, then provides other links to his forms on pages 10 & 11. His steps and forms simplify financial budgeting and spending and are used world wide and has helped thousands of couples over the last 20 plus years. This format will be better for clients who are interested in finding the detail information about how they are using their money. Dependent upon your discernment of the client, either walk through the 5 steps with them or assign it for homework for the next session, as a practical means to take action on their financial needs and accountability.

Obviously, they’re already living paycheck to paycheck, but as they adjust and stop spending money outside of their budgeted amount, with God’s help, they can work together to set aside a little to build up a buffer for savings. There are excellent online programs that will do all of this form them once they enter their basic information. I'd encourage them to do that and either way there are no illusions, fears, insecurities or misunderstandings about where their money goes. 

In this particular case, the power struggles were clouding the real issues of how the money was spent. I confronted them about their tendencies within their personalities to show them why they were arguing. They needed to address the spiritual issues of being submissive to God with your money, and not acting out insecurities through buying or control. Once they made out a budget, they learned how much they were spending beyond what they earned. Over time, they worked to get they spending within their limits.

Question 4

Fully answer the following question from the content you just read and submit your answer to find your score and Dr. Dan's answer to the question.

Write a brief summary of why you believe that the process of patience is critical to establishing good communication, both spiritually and humanly within the marriage.

Pasting is disabled for this answer box. Please type your answer in your own words.


Dr. Dan's Answer:

The main obstacle to closeness is selfishness. Patience forces both parties to submit their opinions to God. When this is done, God will expose anything that is destructive or selfish. He will then enable the person to give up those types of things and to do what is best for the other person. If both do this, neither can lose or feel hurt.

Sexual Issues

Question 5. Our next issue is going to deal with sexuality or sexual issues. We will look from two perspectives: the male and the female. Find the Male Perspective and both analysis questionnaire composite graphs from this Case. Men obtain their sense of being loved through the sexual act. Most women do not know that. It's a different means by which God's created a sense of being loved in a man versus a woman. To the man, the act of being sexual provides his sense and emotional need of acceptance, respect, and being wanted. Most often it's not the same way for a woman. These differences create misunderstandings, because people make wrong assumptions about the other. For example, one sunny Saturday morning after I had worked very hard all week, my wife and I sat in front of a big fireplace in the living room with coffee and coffee cake out. A huge snowstorm had dumped on us overnight. Through our big picture window, we saw the large blue spruce tree loaded with snow on its branches. The fire was roaring in the fireplace, and we were reading our devotions. Everything was absolutely picturesque and idyllic, and my wife let out a contented sigh. She was saying all of my senses tell me that I am loved. A woman’s happiness and feeling loved comes from feeling secure. She felt that way from her surroundings, in a lovely setting and with her husband providing that. All those things said that all her needs were met. That is the primary difference. 

I looked at her and said, “I 'm absolutely miserable.” She was sort of startled and why I was miserable? I explained my weariness from long hours of work and very hard counseling cases. I had done work on the house and more work planned for the day. I said, “There's no payoff in this. I don't care about the fireplace, I don't care about the snow, I don't care about the beautiful house. It doesn't mean anything to me.” I was not angry or hostile, just honest with her. She looked at me and she said, “Well, you are probably lonely, and need to be close to me.” She was so right! We made time for each other being close and making love, and just holding each other. We went back to the living room where the fire had died down. I built it back up, and poured fresh coffee. There wasn't a single thing different than it had been before, except that I had a deep sense in my soul, my mind and my emotions, that I was loved; that all had been worth it. I was close to my woman, and I let out the same kind of sigh that she had given. She laughed, because she understood that men don't get their sense of being loved the same way as women. The man’s belief that his wife accepts him, and is willing to be vulnerable to him, he will work hard at his job, change the oil, and fix the screen at home. There is a willingness to participate in the relationship, because it all makes sense, and it's all worthwhile. 

Even if a woman doesn't have the same desire for sexual expression, it doesn't mean that she can't meet his needs. She does need to understand them. Unfortunately, this is not something that a lot of parents explain to their children. I have to explain this difference to almost every couple I work with, because the misunderstandings about this cause them to be frightened, insecure and angry with each other. One of the most classic examples of this also is when a man comes home, he will go to his wife to hug or hold her. Often, she is busy putting on kids’ tennis shoes, working in the kitchen, or vacuuming. He is looking for the physical response that says, I love you, but she will be saying in her mind, I love you unaware of his need. A woman says I love you through what she does, providing for the family, by cooking, washing the dishes, and cleaning the house. And when a man holds her at the sink, she doesn't understand what he needs. Instead, she thinks he is keeping her from loving him, and may say, “Give me a minute. Don't disturb me. Now, I don't have time for that.” Now, he feels rejection. She's not letting me hold her. He's looking for her to acknowledge his need, and to respond to it. 

This can all change when we ask God for help to understand how to meet the other person’s need. If my wife finds me in the garage and asks me to get a planter down from a hook that is higher than her reach, my first thought is no, I'm working on this carburetor. If I say that to her, then she will feel the same rejection, because I am not meeting her needs. She feels like I am not providing and protecting her. I have to ask the Lord to help me right this second, when that sense of aggravation wells up to stop, think and focus on how I act to meet her need of being loved. The Lord enables me to go out there with a good attitude. I reach up, grab the hook, pull up a little, and the plant is off the hook. She looks at me like I just gave her a million dollars. She thanks me with a sense of spiritual contentment. She sees one more time that I really love her. 

Clients need to understand these differences, so that they each can respond appropriately to meet each other's needs. For example, when the man comes home and puts his arm around her, she asks the Lord to help her remember what he's doing. He's not lusting after me. He's not trying to control me. He's not trying to stop me from meeting his needs in the family or his needs. He's seeking the sense of the pressure of my body leaning back against him or my arms around him that say, I love you. He's seeking the kiss when he comes home that says, “Good job. I'm proud of you. I appreciate your hard work and your effort.” You have to teach your clients to say things like that to each other. My wife tells me thank you for repairing the door or changing the oil. That's another way of her saying, I appreciate your effort. I love you. I care about you. You protect me. And it and it says to me, I'm not a pack horse, I'm not a slave, I'm appreciated. That's another way in which you have your sense of being loved through verbal expressions. So that's the first point here that men obtain their sense of being loved through the sexual act and all the other things that go along with it, like a hug when you come home, the verbal thank you, and the ability to hold hands when you walk. It's all tied in. 

Along with how they sense that they're being loved, is how they are aroused. Arousal in a man is tied to the five senses, like the smell of perfume, the touch of something soft, silk or a dress, even seeing how the wife looks, or just putting his hand on her knee. Men pick up the tactile sense of the touch of the dress or skin. None of this is wrong, but it's been distorted primarily through pornography. Evil distorts things that are good, to get people to sin. Arousal was created as the drive for the man to go back to his wife with a sense of respect and dignity in the marriage, the sexual relationship for the couple is a place of safety. It's supposed to be the place where the wife provides a hedge of safety for the man, so that when he goes into the world he resists temptation, because he is so filled up with the goodness of his sexual relationship with his wife. He has experienced the spiritual goodness, the physical satisfaction, the emotional strength and stability, and closeness so that there is nothing else to tempt him. He knows that what he has is true and godly and good. What is offered in temptation is not true, not godly or good. 

Pornography distorts truths about sexuality. Because men are aroused through the visual image, pornography is tempting. Not everybody gets into hardcore Triple X pornography that is perverted like: multiple partners, sex toys, or bestiality, having sex with an animal. This is difficult, but the reality is some of your clients will have participated in these things, and you will need to understand how they've been controlled and manipulated, to work effectively with them. One of the first lies, when sexuality isn't godly, and misunderstood, is that most men believe they have to perform when being sexual. So being honest isn't an option for them. In other words, they don't have the right to say, I'm tired or please hold me. They don't have the ability to accept a woman being ok without an orgasm, but loving enough to give herself to him. They won't let the wife make love to them, unless that criterion of performance is met. The pornographic lie says that every woman has the exact same level of desire and arousal that you do. As a matter of fact, if you want really good sex, the woman has more desire than you do, and you’ll need to work hard to keep up with her. And the underlying lie is: if you're a real man, you'll be able to do that, with a threat of failure. The truth is in general; most women will have between half to a quarter as much sexual desire as a man does. That varies with her menstrual cycle, stress levels, fatigue and how they receive their sense of being loved. It is not through an orgasm. If a man believes this pornographic lie depicted by the sensual, gaudy clothing, the wife is forced to wear this clothing to get him aroused. She has to pretend that she gets her sense of being loved through the act of intercourse. The women in the pornography have an attitude of hardness and coldness; that their only focus is sex. And they'll even adopt gestures that indicate they're inspecting something to buy with a demanding look. This is even more evident in acts of bondage, or abuse with whips or chains. This conveys the lie that being sexual is about being demanding and harsh. That is not true at all. 

If a couple gets into this type of sexuality, they both lose the ability to be honest with each other.  Saying I'm too tired isn't acceptable. If the man just wants to be held after a demanding or sad day, the man is seen as a wimp, not a real man. There are times I come home from especially hard cases, I have nothing left in me to perform! There may have been spiritual breakthroughs, or someone has been angry and yelled at me, called me stupid, walked out or threatened me. When I get home all sad and tired and sometimes defeated, my wife holds me. I need to be safe with my woman, just be close to her, with her softness smelling like a woman, and to say it's okay. You can't do that if your only option is to constantly perform. You can't have a sense of safety that's wrapped up in just the pure womanliness of your wife. It doesn't exist. 

Men can be very traumatized and stigmatized when you meet them, thinking they have to perform. They don't have the right to be honest. They don't understand that a woman doesn't need an orgasm and wants to be a safe place for him through this act of being sexual with you. This safe, caring place is the way God intended the sexual relationship to be; you are indeed safe and loved and respected. On page 10 you'll see, because of the performance belief, men will not let their wife make love to them without making her have an orgasm. The man considers her interest and action as charity. When you discuss this with the couple, ask the woman about this issue. Ask her about her level of sexual desire, frequency of sexual intercourse, number of times with an organism and what she thinks about her husbands’ desires and needs. You will be amazed, because most women know these things, but they could never get their husband to accept these truths. The man is just amazed that this is true. You will need to ask her, because he won't believe you if you say it. He will believe you if the wife confirms it. That's why you have to ask her if it's true about each point, and then let her contribute any other thoughts she has to the discussion. It's a very intimate thing. It's very personal thing, but you must do this, because if you don't get this cleared up, it's going to cause divisions and fear and frustration and distance between the couple every time. As you're talking about these truths, be looking to the wife. What do you think about this? Do you have any other thoughts? She'll give you or him, examples where these things were true. She tried to tell him, but he didn't listen. They misunderstood. They slept on separate sides in the bed. They were miserable, lonely, frightened, frustrated, because they never got it fixed. It will be a real healing time in this part of the counseling process.

 Let's go back to this issue of charity. In other words, the man will usually be angry, and they'll end up not making love, because what he is hearing her say is, you don't excite me, you don't satisfy me. He has been traumatized by a society of unreality and pornography, even soft pornography. I saw a show the other night with an older fellow and a younger girl attending a baseball game. On their way home, they were talking about going to a motel. He explained what he would do if he wasn't married and was 20 years younger. The last scene showed the man with his wife of 25 years who had bought him a gift. She didn't know he'd gone with this younger girl to see a baseball game. He was lying in bed at three o'clock in the morning, staring at the ceiling, with a very troubled look on his face. His wife had her arm around him sound asleep with a blissful look on her face. He was looking at the illusion that said, if I don't make her happy through the sexual act, then making love is charity. I need to meet this false criterion. The guy was living in a fantasy world that said, if I get into this other relationship, then I'd be happy. On a woman's part, she's simply saying, I'm willing to give you myself as an act of love, because I don't need to have an orgasm in order to feel loved. I will literally feel loved simply because we made love and because the rest of our relationship is right.

Copyright 1987, 1990, 1993 by Daniel D. Wilkinson. All rights reserved. For more information concerning this material, write to:
The Biblical Christian Counseling Ministries, Inc., 2730 Radcliffe Dr., Florissant, MO 63031.
Any reproduction of this material without the express written consent of the author is prohibited. Printed in the U.S.A..

Question 5

Fully answer the following question from the content you just read and submit your answer to find your score and Dr. Dan's answer to the question.

Describe the basic differences in the way that men and women view their sexual relationship.

Pasting is disabled for this answer box. Please type your answer in your own words.


Dr. Dan's Answer:

Men do not realize that women want security, submission to God out of the man. When this is in place a woman is willing to be open, accessible to the man. Submission on the man's part means he says he's sorry, repents, says he's wrong and changes. Women do not understand that God made a man so that his sense of being loved comes from affection and especially sexuality. Hence, he's labeled as lustful when he's looking for affirmation through a pathway that God created, not the man.

You are ready to take Course 4, Chapter 4 Quiz.

Quiz Requirement: A score of 75% is necessary to continue to the next chapter.

Account Access: You must be signed into the coursework page (which is separate from the main CBT website) to take the quiz and advance.

Checking your login status…

One moment please.